Educational Assistance Benefits Compliance 101

When it comes to your educational assistance benefit, compliance is essential for preserving the tax-free nature and impact of any benefit program. Here’s what you need to know about keeping your 127 benefit plan compliant.
The Highway Team
The Highway Team
Last Updated
Published
October 17, 2024

Post Summary

  • Benefits compliance is important because it helps companies meet their legal obligations, avoid penalties or fines, and protect themselves from reputational and financial risk. 
  • For educational assistance benefits, compliance with IRS guidelines is important for a program to remain tax-free
  • Educational assistance benefits should make sure they are not discriminating in favor of HCEs 
  • If a company’s section 127 program is out of compliance, employers may face a range of consequences, including investigation by the IRS, various penalties and/or fees, and potentially owing back taxes.   
  • Highway can help companies set up and administer compliant educational assistance benefit plans from Day 1. 

HR and benefits professionals know that there’s so much more to managing an employee benefits package than just selecting the right mix of benefits–deciding which benefits to offer just the start.

One extremely important, but admittedly tedious, part of benefits management is compliance. Not only do benefits teams need to continually handle all the paperwork related to benefits, they also need to stay on top of continuously updating requirements.

To help simplify things, let’s break down what compliance means and why it matters when it comes to your educational assistance benefits. Read on to learn more. 

– 

What is “benefits compliance”?

In general, “benefits compliance” is the process of making sure that employer-sponsored benefit programs meet any necessary regulations, requirements, or standards set forth by federal and/or state laws, and/or regulating authorities (such as the IRS). 

Why is compliance important for an educational assistance benefit? 

As with many other benefit programs, compliance with federal and state laws is important for an educational assistance because it helps companies:

  • Ensure they are meeting their legal obligations
  • Avoid any steep penalties and/or fines that might result from being out of compliance
  • Protect themselves from reputational and financial risk

For educational assistance benefits, compliance with IRS guidelines is also essential in order for a program to remain exempt from federal income and payroll taxes. 

What are the compliance requirements for an educational assistance benefit? 

Luckily for employers, at a federal level, the compliance requirements for an educational assistance benefit are currently a lot less complex than the requirements for other employee benefits, like 401(K)s or health plans. 

Per the IRS guidelines, companies offering an educational assistance benefit are required to: 

  • Maintain a written plan document 
  • Reasonably notify employees about the benefit and any changes to the benefit plan
  • Limit qualified tax-free assistance to $5,250 per employee per year
  • Limit qualified tax-free assistance for anyone who owns more than 5% of the company or profit interests (i.e. “owners”)  
  • Ensure the plan does not favor Highly-Compensated Employees
  • Maintain any necessary historical records of the plan

While some states may defer to the federal standards for compliance, not all do so companies should always confirm their specific situation with a specialized attorney or tax expert. 

What compliance testing is required for educational assistance benefits?

Even though educational assistance benefits are not currently formally subject to the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), plan sponsors should still ensure that their 127 plans do not favor Highly-Compensated Employees (HCEs) and that owners are not receiving the bulk of the benefit.

Typically, nondiscrimination tests for the different benefit programs evaluate whether a given benefit program discriminates in favor of HCEs on the basis of three things: eligibility criteria, the benefits offering, and utilization.

  • Eligibility Criteria - Who is allowed to enroll in the benefit?
  • Benefit Offering - Are HCEs given more benefits than non-HCES?
  • Utilization - What percentage of HCEs are taking advantage of the benefit relative to non-HCEs (or NHCEs)?

Of course, these testing requirements will vary depending on the benefit in question. 

Under Section 127, educational assistance plans can still pass non-discrimination testing even if the utilization rates for any offered educational assistance varies (or the company requires particular course grades to receive a certain amount of assistance).  

The exception to this would be an Owner Concentration Test, which benefit plan administrators should use to ensure that any owners participating in the educational assistance benefit do not receive more than 5% of the educational assistance paid out to all employees in a given year. For educational assistance benefits, this test is a straightforward formula: 

Total Annual Owners Benefits <= .05*(Total Annual Benefit Paid Out)
Total Annual Owners Benefits <= .05*(Total AnnualBenefit Paid Out)

Where other benefits, such as Cafeteria Plans, Dependent Care Assistance Programs, and Health FSAs, use “Eligibility Tests,” “Average Benefits Tests”, and “Contributions and Benefits Tests” to test eligibility and utilization, educational assistance plan sponsors may be interested in using similar methods (when applicable). 

Breaking down the different types of tests used by other benefits:

  • Eligibility Tests - make sure that a reasonable proportion of non-HCEs are allowed to take advantage of the benefit. This is usually taken care of in plan design. 
  • Average Benefits Tests - test that the average amount of benefit received by HCEs is a reasonable percentage of the average benefit amount received by non-HCES to ensure that HCEs do not disproportionately receive the bulk of benefits. The “reasonable percentage” threshold depends on the benefit in question. 
  • Contributions & Benefits Tests - make sure that the contributions and benefits available to HCEs are not better than those available to non-HCEs (e.g. a plan doesn’t give HCEs 3x the contribution amount of non-HCEs)    

Educational assistance plan sponsors will want to ensure that the ratio of non-HCEs to HCEs who are eligible to participate in their educational assistance benefit satisfactorily meets nondiscrimination testing requirements and that HCEs are not receiving better benefits than non-HCEs.

What are the reporting and filing requirements for educational assistance benefits? 

Under IRC Section 6039D, employers maintaining specified fringe benefits, including educational assistance benefits under Section 127, technically are supposed to maintain records for each year that show:

  1. The number of employees for the year
  2. The number of employees that were eligible to participate in the benefit plan
  3. The number of employees who actually participated in the benefit plan 
  4. The total cost of the plan for the year 
  5. The company’s legal business information, including name, address and EIN
  6. The ratio of highly-compensated employees under sections 1, 2, 3.

To certify this information, employers used to have to file a Form 5500 - Schedule F with the IRS, however in 2002, the IRS suspended this requirement (Notice 2002-24). 

At present, companies offering an educational assistance benefit do not need to file their written plan document or the 6039D plan information with the IRS but they may still want to keep both on hand for their own records. 

What happens if your educational assistance benefit is out of compliance? 

If a company’s section 127 educational assistance benefit program is out of compliance, employers may find themselves facing a range of possibilities. 

In some situations, employers and employees may still be able to exclude the educational assistance from gross income under other sections of the tax code (assuming the assistance satisfies the requirements of those other sections–section 117, section 162 or section 212 of the Internal Revenue code. 

In other situations, employers may potentially face a variety of consequences, some of which may include: investigation by the IRS or other agencies, various penalties and/or fees, and potentially owing back taxes.   

As the consequences may be uncertain, it’s best to avoid the headache entirely and make sure your educational assistance benefit plan remains compliant from the start.

How can Highway Benefits help? 

Keeping up with compliance can feel incredibly daunting, but Highway Benefits is here to help. When you offer an educational assistance benefit through Highway, we help with every step of the process to take all the hassle out of offering a new benefit to your employees.

Our expert team will help you design and administer a benefit plan that's compliant from the start while still meeting your company and talent goals. Schedule a demo with our team today to learn more.   

– 

Disclaimer: This article is purely information and is not intended as financial or legal advice. For more in-depth questions on how to interpret US laws or tax codes, we recommend you speak to a specialized attorney.

The Highway Team

The Highway Team is on a mission to spread knowledge about student loans, the state of the student debt crisis, and impactful benefits like employer student loan repayments. We're here as a helpful resources so drop us a line anytime. Find us on all the major channels as @highwaybenefits

Your next read.

3 things to expect for student loans in 2025: what the election results mean for student loans

3 things to expect for student loans in 2025: what the election results mean for student loans

4 strategies for paying off your student debt faster

4 strategies for paying off your student debt faster

The effect of student debt on the workplace

The effect of student debt on the workplace

Footer illustration for student loan repayments